U.S. Attorney’s OfficeJuly 03, 2012 |
Monday, January 11, 2016
Thursday, July 5, 2012
FBI — Ohio Man Sentenced to 30 Years in Prison for Sex Trafficking of a Minor
Source: FBI
Related articles
- 'Johns' in sweep found in several sites (toledoblade.com)
- Responding to human trafficking requires shift in thinking, trafficking, victims, victim - Local News - LimaOhio.com (trafficking-monitor.blogspot.com)
- FBI Rescues 79 Teens From Prostitution Ring (snspost.com)
- Florida woman named 'Pocahontas' faces life in prison for sex-trafficking teens (miamiherald.com)
- Dallas FBI Rescues 6 Juveniles From Sex Trafficking Operations (dfw.cbslocal.com)
Saturday, March 3, 2012
New law offers hope to sex trafficking victims
SOURCE: Medill Reports - Chicago, Northwestern University. A publication of the Medill School.

BY ARIEL RAMCHANDANI
FEB 29, 2012
Brenda had noticed prostitutes outside her window since she was 9 years old. When her grandmother told her that these women “took off their panties and men gave them money,” Brenda could relate. A latchkey kid, left only in the care of her alcoholic grandmother, Brenda had been molested by men coming in and out of her house since she was 4 years old.
When she had looked out the window and saw these women, who were wearing makeup, and fishnet stockings patrolling the streets, she wanted to be like them.
“I always wanted to be shiny. I couldn’t be shiny because of the things that were happening to me.”
Not long after she began working downtown she was kidnapped by two pimps and held against her will for approximately six months. “They would threaten and say they could shoot me and put me in a cornfield and nobody would know, and I would believe them,” she said.
She finally got away from them after they began to pay attention to another girl they had kidnapped. She never saw the other girl again.
Brenda was one of the many young women in the Chicago area who are commercially sexually exploited. According to the Salvation Army Promise Initiative, 16,000 to 25,000 women are commercially sexually exploited each day in the metropolitan area.
This may come as a surprise to some, who think of trafficking as something that happens in foreign countries.
But “a young woman on one side of the city could be recruited into prostitution and sold in a different neighborhood,” said Kristin Claes, the communications manager at the Chicago Alliance Against Sexual Exploitation.
Since 2007, Illinois has had the fifth highest number of calls to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center hotline of any state.
Legal Action Brenda, who worked all over the country in strip clubs, as an escort and on the streets over the course of her career, is going to be one of the first women in Illinois to petition to have her prostitution conviction vacated on the grounds of her being a trafficking victim.
Illinois recently passed the Justice for Victims of Sex Trafficking Crimes Act. The law, which went into effect in January, aims to help survivors get their lives back. A woman can petition any time after her conviction to prove she was a victim of commercial sex trafficking. Sex trafficking is defined as sexual abuse in exchange for money, goods or services. Judges will look at arrest records, medical records and expert testimony.
“The law is really important because petitioners are asking a judge to recognize that they are sex trafficking victims,” said Claes. The Chicago Alliance Against Sexual Exploitation was a major force behind the law. “This will give recognition by the courts that the victims were not criminals.”
This law comes alongside other measures by the county and state to target human trafficking more effectively and to change the status of women trafficking in prostitution from criminals to victims.
In 2010, Illinois passed the Safe Children’s Act, which was a collaboration between Cook County State’s Attorney Anita Alvarez and the End Demand Illinois campaign. This act wipes the term “juvenile prostitutes” from the criminal code, and sends children arrested for prostitution to social services instead of detention.
Under this law, law enforcement can also go after traffickers through wiretapping.
These laws work together with the Human Trafficking Initiative, also created by the state’s attorney. In this initiative, prosecutors work with law enforcement to coordinate sometimes lengthy investigations. It also networks together nonprofits that help victims.
A difficult game to beat Even on the offensive, law enforcement faces myriad problems in tackling the issue.
The sex trade is highly lucrative. A drug dealer can only sell drugs once, but a pimp can sell a girl multiple times in a day.
“It’s a billion-dollar industry,” Brenda said. “People don’t play when you’re talking about that kind of money. They’re very dangerous, they’re very harsh.”
The director of the Salvation Army’s Promise initiative, which helps trafficking victims, said the hardest part was “disentangling the abusers from the abused.”
“When these pimps starve girls and lock them in a hotel room, and then finally feed them, the girls think, ‘oh they didn’t have to do that,’” he said.
“It’s so hard for a victim to come face-to-face with her victimizers,” Brenda said. “This has been the problem all these years. That’s just the worst thing in the world. Just like a rape victim looking at the person that raped her, but even harder for a victim, because they are brain washed.”
Women like Brenda might also encounter problems as they craft their petitions. Because prostitution is illegal, when Brenda sought out medical treatment she would use different names. She remembers going to Mount Sinai to get treatment after she was shot and then again to get the bullet removed, but medical records in her name only show she got the bullet removed.
“I’m trying to figure out, did I use one name when I got shot and another name to get the bullet out,” she said. “I got frightened because the police were always talking about locking me up.”
The Chicago Alliance Against Sexual Exploitation and the Salvation Army provide legal services to help women craft their cases.
Brenda said she doesn’t know what will happen with her case, or those of other women in the future. “I don’t know because we haven’t even done one yet. We don’t know how this will play out.”
Hold the johns responsible
Those on the front lines of the fight to end trafficking say real change will come when the johns, or clients, are held responsible.
“For too long our culture has blamed women and girls for the harms of prostitution,” said Claes. “Without demand from men there would be no prostitution.”
“When a pimp gets busted, the other pimps know about it, but that doesn’t run them off,” said the director of the Promise program. “When a john gets busted, that runs them off. The biggest admonishment for a john is not that he gets arrested and pays a fine, but that people know.”
For Brenda, the evidence is clear as well.
“You could lock up a drug dealer and a new drug dealer would set up shop immediately, but when they would lock up the customers it would go down. If we hit the demand side as consistently and harshly hard as we hit suppliers, we would have a great impact.”
Cook County Sheriff Thomas J. Dart has organized two National Days of Johns Arrest. On the most recent one, during the Super Bowl, 216 sex purchasers were arrested.
Helping others
Brenda picked up her last client, a white man who looked like he could be a doctor, in a white Mercedes in 1997. When they finished, he began to beat her. As she struggled to leave the car her clothes got stuck in the door. He dragged her six blocks, and the rough concrete scraped the skin off of the left side of her face and body.
In the hospital she met a doctor who helped her get into a safe house, where she lived for a year and a half, reveling in little things people often take for granted, such as being able to open the fridge and make herself something to eat.
Now in her 50s, she runs the Dreamcatcher Foundation, along with another woman she met in that house. The foundation intervenes early to keep girls out of trafficking.
On the day we met she was rushing off to a middle school in Dolton, where a young woman was being trafficked and trying to recruit other girls. Brenda’s goal was to bring the girl to Anne’s House, a safe house run by the Promise program.
Asked as she gathered up her coat to leave if she was worried at all that the girl wouldn’t come, that she might not trust her, she replied:
“Yeah, they’re going to trust me,” she said. “I’m a diva.”
- Fighting sex trafficking in hotels, one room at a time - CNN.com (trafficking-monitor.blogspot.com)
- Truckers asked to help stop sex trafficking - www.ktnv.com (trafficking-monitor.blogspot.com)
- Q&A -- Anti-slavery activist to speak in Acton - Acton, MA - The Beacon (trafficking-monitor.blogspot.com)
- House approves sex trafficking study | ajc.com (trafficking-monitor.blogspot.com)
Monday, February 27, 2012
Marcia G. Yerman: Girls Likes Us -- Rachel Lloyd's Memoir Illuminates the Sexual Exploitation of Children
2/27/2012
The first time I heard Rachel Lloyd speak was in 2005, the year of the 70th Annual Academy Awards. "It's Hard Out Here for a Pimp" had won for the best song of the year. Whenever I complained about that song being showcased, people would tell me to "lighten up." Yet when Lloyd stepped up to address the issue of human trafficking, she brought up that song, and the disconnect between reality and what the Hollywood version of life on the street entails.
Since then, while covering the topic of human trafficking, I have seen Lloyd talk at numerous events and panels. I have called her up for quotes and insights, such as the time football starLawrence Taylor was arrested. I had needed to get a lucid response on why the media was portraying an under-age trafficked girl as a "hooker."
Lloyd always speaks the truth to power. It may be to a New York City police commissioner, or a Manhattan audience learning for the first time that 13-year-old African-American girls in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn are being bought and sold. Lloyd frequently notes that they are part of an estimated 200,000-300,000 adolescents who are at risk for commercial sexual exploitation in the United States annually.
Consequently, it was no surprise to me that the memoir Lloyd had penned, Girls Like Us: Fighting for a World Where Girls Are Not for Sale, an Activist Finds Her Calling and Heals Herself, would be a tough, gritty and brutally honest account. Lloyd traces how a difficult childhood led to a hair-raising journey that encompassed risk, recruitment, and violent abuse--to breaking free from sexual exploitation...and ultimately healing. She now is a top activist in the anti-trafficking movement.
Finding her purpose in working with girls "in the life," Lloyd connects to those in crisis based on shared experiences, understanding without judgment, and respect. Founding Girls Educational and Mentoring Services (GEMS) in 1998, Lloyd went back to school to attain her GED, going on to receive a Bachelors degree in Psychology from Marymount Manhattan College and a Masters in Applied Urban Anthropology from the City College of New York. She has racked up numerous awards for her work, all while "owning her experience."
Girls Like Us presents a dual story thread. One is Lloyd's personal narrative; the other is a primer on what trafficked American girls are up against. Lloyd outlines the factors that make girls vulnerable, examines how they are sexually exploited, and discusses the role of pimps, johns, and cops in the equation. The inherent difficulties of overcoming the trauma of sexual servitude often mimic the symptoms of Stockholm syndrome and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).
Lloyd breaks down one fallacy after another, many unfortunately believed by social workers, law enforcement officials, and those making decision calls in the judicial system. If misconceptions could start to be addressed, perhaps a real awareness toward new solutions could be innovated.
There is so much that needs to change, and Lloyd points out the problems with crystal clarity. One of her frequent talking points is the statistic that the estimated median age of entry into the commercial sex industry occurs between the ages of 12 and 14. Defining the difference between an "exploited child and a prostitute" is a full time endeavor. She explains that "leaving the life takes practice," and that girls need to have the unfailing support of a person who will not "give up on them." Most important to note are the socioeconomic causes, that for some baffling reason appears more comprehensible when they occur in foreign countries, but which are insufficiently grasped on our own national turf.
Lloyd posits that too often the wrong questions are asked. Instead of taking a facile approach to a girl's situation with the query, "Why doesn't she just leave?"--Lloyd suggests an examination of the impact of poverty, homelessness, and neglect, along with "race and class factors."
With over 500,000 children in New York City living in poverty, the risk factor is high. A 2007 study showed that 75 percent of sexually exploited and trafficked children in New York City were in foster care at some point. Connect the dots to an ineffective support system, and you end up with a "policy that blames the victim."
For police who don't understand that captivity isn't an issue of being physically tied and bound, it can be frustrating to explain the depths of a "trauma bond" in an existence predicated on terror. Leaving the life and making the transition is difficult. As Lloyd says, "Healing is a messy, complicated process that's rarely linear." It doesn't help that society--even those tasked with supporting victims--often relay the message that the girl's "exploitation was their choice," leaving them with a burden of blame and shame.
One of the major challenges is the need to reframe not only attitudes, but also language. The United Nations and UNICEF have adopted the term commercially sexually exploited child/youth to reference those who are underage. New terminology will help grow novel thinking. Once assimilated into the collective mindset, a change can start to be reflected in the media and popular culture. As Lloyd emphasizes, most of America didn't have trouble understanding the trauma of Elizabeth Smart. But when you shift from her story to a 14-year-old girl of color in the Bronx, the reaction is totally different.
Girls Like Us puts it all out there -- no holds barred. In addition to the contribution that Lloyd has made with her book filled with detailed veracity and visceral punch, she has left the public with nothing to hide behind.
There can no longer be the question, "Who knew?"
Fight child exploitation and get involved with organizations such as GEMS.
Girls Like Us comes out in paperback on February 28, 2012
This article originally appeared on the website mgyerman.com
Follow Marcia G. Yerman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/mgyerman
Saturday, February 25, 2012
WTRF.com SPECIAL REPORT: Human Trafficking and the Ohio Valley - WTRF 7 - Wheeling Steubenville
When you hear the term "human trafficking" most of us would think of a foreign country or at most a big city, but like many crimes, its on the rise and showing up in the least likely of areas and the Ohio Valley could be next.
"Human trafficking" in short, is the illegal trade of human beings for the purposes of reproductive slavery, commercial sexual exploitation, forced labor, or a modern-day form of slavery.
In cities across the country, law enforcement are beginning to see a boom in this once obsolete world.
What was once looked at as simple prostitution now involves girls as young as 12 years old.
"It targets those individuals that have been abused or neglected. A lot of the time that just so happens to be a young girl, " said Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine.
Attorney General Dewine is one of the leading men across the country in the fight against human trafficking.
Just recently Ohio and Pennsylvania adopted stricter laws and punishments and just this week West Virginia got on board and passed new legislation as well.
Attorney General DeWine told WTRF.com, "it's something every state should be looking into if they're not already. We're not just seeing this type of thing in the larger cities, but also as far reaching as the suburbs."
When asked if the Ohio Valley may be a target area for future human trafficking, Dewine said, "it's tough to say exactly where it will be seen, especially because this is still something new for law enforcement. What you have to understand is the recipe of what causes it. If you have a certain economy that is beginning to grow, an influx of out of town workers, and people willing to break the law, then of course."
Attorney General DeWine said he hopes to continue strengthening Ohio's laws against human trafficking and working with other state lawmakers to do the same.
Related articles
- Truckers asked to help stop sex trafficking - www.ktnv.com (trafficking-monitor.blogspot.com)
- Human Trafficking: Runaways Are a Target (trafficking-monitor.blogspot.com)
Friday, February 17, 2012
The new Christian abolition movement – CNN Belief Blog - CNN.com Blogs
Greensboro, North Carolina (CNN) —The truck-stop hooker is no Julia Roberts, the trucker in the cab with her no Richard Gere, and this truck stop off the highway could not be any farther from Beverly Hills, the staging ground for “Pretty Woman.”
The woman sports baggy shorts, a white T-shirt and frizzy hair. Her fat middle-aged pimp sits in a beat up red Honda, watching as his “lot lizard” moves from truck to truck, in broad daylight. If this pimp has a cane it is for substance, not style.
She moves through the parking lot, occasionally opening a cab’s passenger-side door and climbing in.
The trucker and hooker disappear in the back for 10 minutes.
Danielle Mitchell watches from the other end of the parking lot and shakes her head.
“We know from talking to other victims and other agencies that girls are taken to truck stops and they’re actually traded,” she says, sitting in her car, a shiny silver sport utility vehicle, keeping a healthy 50-yard distance from the pimp.
CNN's Belief Blog – all the faith angles to the day's top stories
Mitchell is North Carolina human trafficking manager for World Relief. World Relief is a Christian nonprofit attached to the National Association of Evangelicals and is best known for its efforts to combat global hunger and respond to disasters around the world.
Mitchell is trying to tackle a disaster in her home state. And she is not alone.
Motivated in large part by their religious traditions of protecting the vulnerable and serving “the least of these,” as Jesus instructed his followers to do in the Gospel of Matthew, World Relief and other Christian agencies like the Salvation Army are stepping up efforts and working with law enforcement to stem the flow of human trafficking, which includes sex trafficking and labor trafficking.
“Jesus didn’t just go around telling people about himself. He also healed the blind and healed the brokenhearted, he freed captives, and I think that it would be ridiculous to walk up to someone who is hurting and tell them, ‘Let me tell you about the Gospel,’ and then walk away while they’re still hurting,” Mitchell says.
In North Carolina, the result of those efforts can be seen in the number of victims of human trafficking being referred to World Relief for services, up 700% in 2011, Mitchell says.
“It’s not that North Carolina is all of a sudden trafficking more people,” Mitchell says. “It’s that we know what to look for and we’re actually identifying and rescuing them.”
Truck stops and sweet potatoes
North Carolina’s rich soil makes it an agricultural hub. It produces more sweet potatoes than anywhere else in the country. The state acts as a crossroads for three major interstate highways. The mix of accessibility and low-paying farm jobs make a good working environment for traffickers, Mitchell says.
This truck stop is the type you think twice about. It’s grimy and run down.
How badly do I really have to use the bathroom? I bet I could hold out for another 12 miles. That kind of place.
Mitchell walks in and politely asks the women behind the register if they have tape.
“Over there, honey,” the cashier says, pointing to a dimly lit portion of the store.
After paying for a roll of industrial packing tape, she tucks it in her purse and heads for the restroom.
In a stall on the far end, she shuts the door behind her and pulls out the tape and a poster with words in English and Spanish.
“Need help?” the poster asks. “Are you being forced to do something you don’t want to do?” There’s a toll free number, 888-373-7888, for the National Human Trafficking Hotline, run by the nonprofit Polaris Project.
More on the fight against modern-day slavery at the CNN Freedom Project
“A lot of times when girls are being trafficked they’re being controlled,” Mitchell says. “They’re often not allowed to get very far from their trafficker. And we’ve found one of the very few times girls are alone is when they’re in the bathroom.”
She used to ask if she could hang posters in truck stop restrooms. Now she just hangs them.
That toll free hot line number is plastered on combs, lip balms and nail files that Mitchell and other anti-trafficking workers can slip discreetly to men and women they suspect might be victims. Slipping a potential client an anti-trafficking business card could be dangerous, even deadly, they say.

A comb, nail file and lip balm feature the number for the National Human Trafficking Hotline.
But it’s not the only way Mitchell gets in touch with victims. Law enforcement is reaching out to her more and more.
When North Carolina law enforcement breaks up a trafficking ring, they call her.
She helps the victims get safe places to live, food and job training, along with just being a conversation partner.
Since 2010, North Carolina has had a statewide coalition to fight human trafficking. Law enforcement officers are now trained in what to look for. The program includes rapid response teams made up of representatives from law enforcement, service providers, hospitals and charities. When a potential victim comes into a hospital or is discovered through an arrest, the team springs into action.
“Victims are not going to self-identify,” says Mitchell, who has since left World Relief and is considering going back to school after a lack of funding threatened to cut her hours to part time. “ They’re not going to say ‘I’m a victim of human trafficking.’ So the burden is really on the service providers and law enforcement and the community."
In North Carolina, the partnerships between those groups, she says, “have helped to rescue victims.”
Church and state in an unlikely coalition
Christian groups working to combat trafficking are providing law enforcement with some much-needed relief.
“Because of the limitations of our work, we like to partner with organizations that can provide services,” says Kory Williford, a victim specialist with the FBI based in North Carolina.
“Human trafficking isn’t the only victim population we work with, so to have organizations who can provide care to our victims on a longer term basis than we are able to is huge,” she says.
“A lot of sex trafficking is occurring in this state” and labor trafficking is on the upswing, Williford says.
The FBI in North Carolina has been partnering with World Relief for several years.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Anand P. Ramaswamy, who focuses on human trafficking cases across the state from the federal prosecutors office in Greensboro, says he has been collaborating with local law enforcement on human trafficking.
“Those kind of cases have only recently been on the uptick,” he says. “As officers become more trained in what to look for, the number of cases goes up.”
The nation and the state are still working to catch up with the reality of trafficking, he says.
“Sometimes the victim was treated as part of the problem,” he says. “In one instance a 16-year-old girl was charged with prostitution by local authorities. So we have to go and sort of undo that. That’s also the case where the person may have done something wrong, so they’re reluctant to come forward.”
Ramaswamy is keenly aware that his office and religious groups do not always have the same interests. His is in upholding and enforcing the law, while religious groups are interested in practicing their religion.
But the assistant U.S. attorney still believes in the partnership between church and state.
“On one hand the fact they’re a religious organization is not directly relevant,” he says. “However, if you look at the history of the abolitionist movement, it has always been religious communities and those are the people who are concerned enough to be active in it.
“And today with modern-day slavery the same is the case.”
The new Underground Railroad
Westover Church in Greensboro, North Carolina, is imagining what fighting modern-day slavery could look like. The nondenominational suburban church is cut from an evangelical cloth and has 5,000 members and a sprawling campus.
In 2011, the church started a ministry called “Abolition!” to fight human trafficking. It focuses on prayer, awareness and resources.
“In truth we didn’t know what we were going to do. We just knew we had a really strong passion for it,” says Dianne Stone, an "Abolition!" member. “We didn’t want to be a group that got together and said, ‘Oh we feel so bad for this.’ We wanted to do something and we wanted to make a difference.”
In a bright room off the sanctuary, Stone, Cambre Weller and Jennifer Craver, all members the group, explain why they got involved. They seem unlikely fighters against trafficking.
They could easily pass for a women’s Bible study group as they casually chat about their children and church activities before turning their attention to trafficking concerns in their area.
“It’s another thing to realize this is in your backyard and that’s our responsibility to address that and protect those who are being exploited,” Craver says.
What's the role of faith in fighting slavery?
Craver says the things they have learned about trafficking are horrible and keep her up at night. “I don’t want to know about trafficking, but I do know about it and as a Christian, I feel like I have to respond to that,” she says. “That is part of my calling.”
The group screens documentaries about human trafficking at other churches and sends out speakers to the Christian circuit. They also prepare emergency bags: canvas totes with a comb, brush, journal, pajamas, clean towels and other basics they learned that most trafficked women don’t have.
They keep a ready stash of bags for World Relief to distribute to victims, particularly those who are rescued during raids.
Mitchell says her faith has played a large role in her work to help victims of trafficking. “I don’t think I’m any different than anyone I work with, in vulnerability or dignity,” she says. “And man, I really believe that Christ saw everyone equally.”

Danielle Mitchell views her faith as integral to her work in fighting human trafficking.
“I could have been born in a brothel in India,” she says.
But there is a limit to how much personal faith she shares with clients.
“We’re completely client centered,” she says. “That means we’re not going to force our faith on anyone. And I don’t talk to the clients about what I believe, unless they ask me.”
“If a client asks me and they want to go to a Buddhist temple, then I’m going to take them because that’s what they want.”
Prostituted not prostitute
Back at the truck stop, Mitchell explains that she hates the term “prostitute” and despises the phrase “lot lizard.” She says it strips people of their dignity.
Instead, she refers to a “woman or man who is being prostituted.” It is a slight change in wording that reveals a starkly different viewpoint.
“A lot of people think of sex trafficking or prostitution, they think it’s glamorous and that you can pinpoint someone who is selling sex or being sold for sex,” she says. “Usually it’s just average people who maybe aren’t taking care of themselves."
The prostitute, or woman being prostituted, or potential human trafficking victim, gets back into the beat up red Honda with the overweight pimp, who drives off, maybe after catching a glimpse of a journalist and activist watching them from a safe distance.
Mitchell calls the police to report what she just saw.
A few hours later, they call back and say the alleged pimp and alleged prostitute are long gone.
Eric Marrapodi - CNN Belief Blog Co-Editor |
Related articles
- Trucker Calls Make a Difference (trafficking-monitor.blogspot.com)