SOURCE:latimes.com
September 15, 2012
Trafficking Monitor is a blog I created and curate. It offers posts highlighting the multifaceted nature of human trafficking and forced/indentured labour. I draw on a diversity of sources for my posts. You are invited to recommend materials for posting.
The Ugandan women, aged between 19 and 42, were rescued from an apartment block near Kuala Lumpur in a sting operation, which also led to the arrest of one male and two female members of the trafficking ring.
The apartment block was put under police surveillance after one of the Ugandan women managed to escape and sought police help. The rescued women have been transferred to a welfare home and are expected to be deported later.
Police said the women, who were promised well-paying hotel jobs in Malaysia by "recruitment agents" in their home country, were brought into Malaysia via China. But they were later forced to have sex with African men residing in Malaysia by the ring members.
The women were beaten up and locked in rooms by the ring members if they refused to have sex with the customers in exchange for money or attempt to escape. The detained ring members now face up to 15 years in prison if convicted on human trafficking charges.
Malaysia has been criticized in the past for not enforcing laws against human trafficking. The South Asian country has been on the US government's human trafficking watch list since last year.
Previously, Malaysia also figured in the US list of of nations with worst human trafficking records for three years. The upgraded status was prompted by the Malaysian government's stepped up efforts to curb sexual exploitation of women and children in the country.
by RTT Staff Writer
A Malaysian workers' rights group urged Cambodia on Friday to stop supplying housemaids to Malaysia, claiming many are abused and made to work like slaves because of inadequate protection.
By EILEEN NG
Associated Press
A Malaysian workers' rights group urged Cambodia on Friday to stop supplying housemaids to Malaysia, claiming many are abused and made to work like slaves because of inadequate protection.
Malaysia has recruited thousands of Cambodian women since neighboring Indonesia barred domestic workers from coming to Malaysia in 2009 following a string of high-profile cases of assault by employers.
Officials estimate there are more than 50,000 Cambodian maids in Malaysia, including 30,000 who arrived this year.
A Cambodian maid was found dead in Malaysia last month under mysterious circumstances, while another was rescued by Malaysian police after she was allegedly abused and had her head shaved bald by her employer.
Irene Fernandez, director of the rights group Tenaganita, said her organization helped another 41 Cambodian maids, some as young as 15, after they were rescued or ran away from their employers in the past six months because of abuse or unpaid wages.
"Today, another nation of domestic workers goes through the same experiences of torture, control and denial of rights," Fernandez said in a statement. "Cambodian maids now remain in a condition of forced labor with practices of modern day slavery."
Tenaganita urged Cambodia to ban maids from coming to Malaysia until tougher laws are enacted to protect their rights.
Malaysia is among Southeast Asia's top importers of foreign labor, employing more than 200,000 mainly Indonesian maids. Many households rely on maids for cooking, cleaning and looking after children and the elderly.
Indonesia is expected to lift its ban on maids after signing a deal with Malaysia in May for better conditions to curb abuses.
Ung Vantha, an official with the Cambodian Embassy in Kuala Lumpur, said his government is concerned about abuse and is working with authorities and activists to tackle the problem.
The embassy is investigating claims that the maid found dead last month was beaten by her employers, he said. Police have said the girl died of pneumonia.
Visiting Cambodian opposition lawmaker Mu Sochua said the maid, who was found dead outside her employer's house, was only 15, according to her family, and not 22 as stated on her passport. Domestic workers in Malaysia must be at least 21.
"We are talking about child labor here. Young girls from poor families are targeted by middlemen who falsified their age in their passport," she said.
Malaysian police and immigration officials familiar with maid issues could not be immediately reached.
Fernandez said about half of the 41 Cambodian maids helped by Tenaganita were under 21. All claimed they were overworked, not given days off and had their passports confiscated by employers.
More than half alleged they suffered physical abuse, while about one-fifth were believed to be sexually harassed.
Most returned to Cambodia after Tenaganita negotiated for compensation and wage settlements with their employers. They did not seek police help because they were depressed and eager to return home, Fernandez said.

file-pix
The HRW noted that under the current system, companies are not responsible for sending unwanted migrant workers back to their countries of origin.
The desperation of these workers to pay off the hefty debts they have incurred during the employment period, entraps them in a system of debt bondage. And debt bondage, according to the HRW, is human trafficking.
This latest criticism follows Tenaganita's pronouncement that Malaysia is among the leading countries in the estimated US$13 billion (RM41.2 billion) a year global black market involving human trafficking.
Phil Robertson, the deputy director of the HRW Asia division, pinned the root of the problem on the recruitment agencies that act as middlemen.
“You couldn't have devised a worse system if you tried,” he said. “Not only is it (recruitment system) rife with corruption and human rights abuses, it also outsources the responsibility of hiring the migrant workers to shadowy employers and prevents the establishment of any systematic regulation.”
Robertson also dismissed the Home Ministry's promise to review the system of using recruitment companies to hire migrant workers as “not credible at all”.
“Most of these companies are fly-by-night operators,” he said. “The ministry must study what incentives the system encourages and from there introduce a systemic reform of bringing migrant workers into the country.”
“The fact is that Malaysia cannot run its economy without migrant workers. They have been integrated into the production, manufacturing, agricultural and family lives of thousands of Malaysians. To continue treating them so shoddily is also extremely short-sighted.”
This criticism is likely to call attention to Malaysia's recent election to the United Nations Human Rights Council (HRC) barely three months ago.
Malaysia's inclusion in the council drew condemnation from various international quarters but had the backing of others like HRW, which viewed it as an opportunity to push Malaysia to clean up its poor human rights record.
Robertson, who was in Kuala Lumpur last week to speak on human trafficking at the 15th Malaysian Law Conference, also spoke to FMT on Malaysia's seat on the HRC and the role of the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam).
FMT: Do you think Malaysia takes its seat on the UNHRC seriously?
Robertson: It's hard to tell. My sense of Malaysia's motivation is that it wants to be seen as a progressive modern nation that understands the interest and demands of the international community. But there almost seems to be a double game here. The face that Malaysia projects to the international community is very different from what it projects to Malaysians.
Even Malaysia's election campaign was very interesting. All the nominees must draw up a set of pledges of what they will do if they are elected to the council. In Thailand, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs had a big party where its minister and prime minister handed out pamphlets detailing Thailand's pledges to the guests.
In Malaysia there was nothing. In fact, local human rights organisations weren't even sure whether Malaysia was really running. And they weren't able to get a copy of the pledges that Malaysia was making to other countries. HRW had to go to another mission at the United Nations in order to get a copy of the pledges. It was almost like a stealth campaign.
So time will tell. HRW is glad Malaysia is on the council but it's not a free ride. Malaysia needs to show some serious intent and if it doesn't within a year or two from now, then it will have some explaining to do.
What is Malaysia most serious human rights violation?
The most egregious continuing violation is preventive detention and I'm not just talking about the Internal Security Act (ISA) but also the Emergency Ordinance Act (EOA) and the Dangerous Drugs Act (DDA).
It is very disturbing when someone who is arrested on a criminal charge is released by the court but only to be re-arrested as soon as he walks out. It's almost like a double jeopardy violation. The fact that the court and the law enforcers use two separate laws is of significant concern.
In your opinion, is Suhakam relevant?
Yes. I've had a very good meeting with the new Suhakam commissioners and I'm impressed by their openness. I'd say that they are cautiously optimistic.
But for things to really change the Malaysian government needs to start viewing Suhakam as a valued partner. Suhakam can bring a lot to the table if it is respected and given a proper chance. There are many different human rights issues where the government doesn't have the expertise and it should look to Suhakam for help. And Suhakam should also be strong and consistent in its position.
How would you rate human rights in Malaysia?
I've long learnt that rating countries vis-a-vis each other just gets you into trouble so I will not give a rating. I will say, however, that the problem with Malaysia is that there's always a promise of something better but there's very little follow-up.
The governance is so opaque that it's very difficult to see and understand what is going on. I go back to the stark contrast between appearance and reality. Malaysian ministers talk differently in Washington from what they do at home.
The government should have more faith in the people. It must understand that they are not radicals but people who want to be heard, participate in governance and be involved in decision-making. The government must trust its people more and one way of doing it is to respect their human rights.
Magistrate Nelson W. Angang granted the remand order after considering the request by the police to carry out investigations under the Anti-Trafficking in Persons Act, 2007 and to identify the children involved.
Police yesterday found a three-year-old toddler and 12-year-old girl in a house in Batu Kawa. This brings the number of rescued children to six.
From left: A businessman carrying the title ‘Datuk’, his 24-year-old son and a relative were among the 10 suspects brought in court for the baby trafficking case. The children were all brought to court yesterday and some of the babies were crying uncontrollably.
It is learnt that they were initially supposed to be sent to a shelter in Kuala Lumpur but were later placed under the custody of the state Welfare Department.
Police believe the 43-year-old Datin could be the mastermind of the alleged syndicate.
She and her husband, who is 65, were detained at their house at Jalan Stampin Tengah on Wednesday morning when the police “rescued” three children at their residence.
All three children have documentation; one infant girl was registered with a couple, while two boys were registered under another couple.
The two couples, who were also remanded, are believed to be the Datin’s relatives.
Out of the woods: A baby and a toddler among six rescued from the suspected human trafficking syndicate. The other two suspects remanded are a local woman and an Indonesian woman believed to be the Datin’s friends.
They were arrested at 1.24am and 2.15am at their house at Green Height and Batu Kawah respectively yesterday.
The suspected baby trafficking syndicate was exposed following the rescue of an infant at Batu Kawah new township in an undercover police operation.
The baby was allegedly to be sold for RM10,000.
A woman who carried the baby during the bust has been detained under the Immigration Act. Judging by the ages of some of the children rescued, the suspected ring could have been operating for quite some time.
Datuk, wife and six others held in baby trafficking probe
Image via Wikipedia