Showing posts with label San Francisco Bay Area. Show all posts
Showing posts with label San Francisco Bay Area. Show all posts

Sunday, November 30, 2014

» The new social network: local organizations diminishing modern slavery

Almost 150 years after the thirteenth amendment legally abolished slavery, we’re still fighting for freedom.
In my previous article, modern day slavery was explored through the complex, multi-layered system of human exploitation that permeates our everyday lives. Known as our slavery footprint, what we buy connects us to people across the world as well as right here at home.
Pervasive and seemingly intangible as today’s slavery is, the Bay Area is trailblazing the path towards the end of the many kinds of oppression ranging from the maltreatment of coffee farmers in rural Ecuador to the more notorious sex trafficking on International Blvd.
Read more
» The new social network: local organizations diminishing modern slavery:

Related articles

Friday, March 16, 2012

Online Sex Trade Flourishing Despite Efforts to Curb It - NYTimes.com

Online Sex Trade Flourishing Despite Efforts to Curb It -


Source: NYTimes.com



Among the sites that serve the sex trade is one with an interactive map of massage parlors and reviews of places like The Green Door in San Francisco.
Early this month, the social networking Web site itspimpin101.net fell into disarray after its founder, Kelly Surrell, was fatally wounded in a shooting while driving his Bentley in East Oakland.

For years, Mr. Surrell, 34, had profited by taking a portion of the earnings of his roster of women prostitutes. Then, like many Internet entrepreneurs, Mr. Surrell decided to capitalize on an expanding online community. On his Web site, which referred visitors to Mr. Surrell’s Facebook page and his instructional podcasts, pimps and aspiring pimps could post tips and swap advice about “the game.”

They will have to go somewhere else now, because Mr. Surrell’s social network is “currently undergoing maintenance,” according to a message posted there. But it appears that there are more places than ever for them to go.
The online sex trade is flourishing despite nationwide campaigns and pressure from government leaders. Two years after public and legal pressure prompted Craigslist.org, the San Francisco-based online classifieds service, to scrap its “erotic services” section, visitors and revenue have soared on other classified Web sites, according to the Advanced Interactive Media Group, a consulting firm for the classified advertising market. Law enforcement officials in the Bay Area said other Web sites had emerged with suspected sex-for-pay advertisements.
The sites display ads for sex services, and they also serve as online communities where customers, pimps and prostitutes can arrange business deals, share police sightings and swap tips. Law enforcement officials said the online trade has, in some ways, made sex trafficking and solicitation easier, while giving the police new insight into a historically hidden, underground culture.
“It’s a great tool for us, to be honest,” said Detective Jeremy Martinez of the San Jose Police Human Trafficking Task Force. “I know there was a lot of applause when Craigslist’s erotic services got brought down, but for us it was a fishing pond we could go to.”
Casey Bates, who supervises the Alameda County district attorney’s human trafficking unit, said law enforcement officials have “a love-hate relationship” with online sex sites. “It’s despicable, what’s going on,” Mr. Bates said, “but they allow us to show a jury in very graphic terms what’s going on between provider and john.”
Law enforcement officials said the most popular sites for listing sex-related services in the Bay Area include the social media and review Web site myredbook.com and Village Voice Media’s classified advertising site backpage.com. Other sites offer additional features, from lovings.com, which verifies escort-submitted photographs, to rubmaps.com, which features an interactive map of adult massage parlors and user-submitted reviews of masseuses, down to detailed descriptions of their sexual prowess.
On myredbook.com, customers calling themselves “hobbyists” share reviews of “providers,” whose photos, phone numbers, services and prices are listed on their profiles. In some forums on the site, other users post photographs of women they see walking on the street, including on “Inty,” or International Boulevard in Oakland, the notorious stretch for prostitution known as “the track.” Many post warnings to other users, in real time, when they spot police officers, or claim to have been robbed or ripped off by a pimp, prostitute or customer.
“The Internet is that frontier out there,” Detective Martinez said. “Anyone can post, even if it’s about something illegal. The good thing about that is we have a place to look.”
At least one site owner does not find the idea alarming.
“These places have been around since the beginning of time, basically,” said Warren Newsome, a spokesman for rubmaps.com, the only site to respond to an inquiry from The Bay Citizen. “We don’t play referee. We just provide a forum. It’s better to provide this medium where cops can get some info, rather than not have any.”
Earlier this month, the San Francisco Police Department received a report that a suspected pimp had kidnapped a young woman at 10th Street and Mission. With a description and photograph in hand, investigators with the special victims unit searched on myredbook.com for the missing woman, filtering the profiles by age and hair color. After finding her profile, a detective contacted the listed cellphone number and arranged to meet with her at a nearby motel, where officers took her into custody.

“It’s a good way to gather intelligence,” said Detective Vincent Repetto of the special victims unit. “You get this kind of information and it can dovetail with open investigations.”

Late last year, the police in South San Francisco arrested a couple after finding them and two 16-year-old girls, including one runaway, in their motel room. Mahendar Singh, 40, told the authorities that the girls were his stepdaughters, but the police found their profiles on myredbook.com. In January, Mr. Singh pleaded guilty to federal charges of conspiring to commit sex trafficking.
Challenging the sites legally has proven difficult. Legal experts said the Web sites are protected by the Communications Decency Act of 1996, which states that Web site owners are exempt from responsibility for the content of their users.
“The idea is that you hold the speaker liable, and not the soapbox,” said Rebecca Jeschke, director of media relations for the Electronic Frontier Foundation. “It’s the foundation of the Internet you see now.”
In August, a judge dismissed a lawsuit against Village Voice Media that claimed backpage.com was aiding and abetting sex trafficking by allowing users to post advertisements for sex.
Investigators said that trying to battle the Web sites in a public or legal arena is not the solution to the problem; providers simply write in code — offering “French lessons,” for example — or move to other Web sites. Some Web sites are hosted in other countries, such as rubmaps.com, which lists its business address in Nicosia, Cyprus.
“Maybe the best thing to do is to block a site or take it down, but it just pops up in a different form,” said Mr. Bates, of the Alameda district attorney’s office.
Lawmakers have been slow to realize the scope of the problem. In 2007, two years after California lawmakers made human trafficking a felony, the attorney general’s office released a report on human trafficking in the state. The Internet was not mentioned.
But California is now leading the country in responding to the rapidly expanding online sex trade. In February, Attorney General Kamala D. Harris convened leaders from nonprofit, law enforcement and technology companies to gather information for an updated report on human trafficking in the state. Several researchers who are a part of the group, including some from Microsoft and the University of Southern California’s Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism, are developing a database that would allow law enforcement officials to search and map information from all of the Web sites suspected of advertising prostitution.
“This is an opportunity to observe the social behaviors which underlie the trafficking trade, which is essential if you want to combat it,” said Mark Latonero, director of research at the Annenberg Center on Communication Leadership and Policy. “We’re trying to crack the code.”
swalter@baycitizen.org
Related articles
Enhanced by Zemanta

Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Slave labor targeted in Calif. law, social media  | ajc.com

http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/slave-labor-targeted-in-1282059.html

The Associated Press
SAN FRANCISCO — Justin Dillon's rock band was touring Eastern Europe when he met some college students who told him they were about to get work in the West. They were eager to begin what they were sure would be their new MTV-like lives.
In this photo taken Dec. 21, 2011, Justin Dillon is photographed at the Fair Trade office in Oakland, Calif. Dillon, a Bay Area rocker, has become a big name in the anti-slavery movement by working with the State Department in a new social media campaign against exploitation of workers. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)
In this photo taken Dec. 21, 2011, Justin Dillon is photographed at the Fair Trade office in Oakland, Calif. Dillon, a Bay Area rocker, has become a big name in the anti-slavery movement by working with the State Department in a new social media campaign against exploitation of workers. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)
In this photo taken Dec. 21, 2011, Justin Dillon is photographed at the Fair Trade office in Oakland, Calif. Dillon, a Bay Area rocker, has become a big name in the anti-slavery movement by working with the State Department in a new social media campaign against exploitation of workers. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)
  • The legislation introduced by Senate President Pro Tem Darrell Steinberg requires companies to audit and certify that their suppliers are complying with international labor standards, as well as provide training to supply-chain managers.
Dillon dug deeper and asked to see their documents. He warned the young women they likely were about to be trafficked into the sex trade or sweatshops.
They brushed him off. They wanted desperately to believe the $2,200 they had paid a facilitator to get them service industry jobs would make all their dreams come true.
"They immediately felt embarrassed, but then emboldened," he recalls of the 2003 exchange. "They said, 'I mean, look around. I'll take my chances on this. You think I'm going to stick around here?'"
That conversation changed his life — and his life's mission.
Today, the 42-year-old Berkeley rocker heads up a popular social media campaign to combat slavery. With a $200,000 grant from the State Department, he recently launched www.slaveryfootprint.org , which helps people identify the slave labor used for their own consumer goods. It is approaching 2 million hits.
He belongs to a coalition of anti-slave labor groups sharing an $11.5 million grant from Google's philanthropy arm.
And now — with the help of a groundbreaking anti-slavery retail law going into effect across California on New Year's Day — Dillon believes the movement is reaching that tipping point where the average consumer can make a difference.
"We need cultural critical mass on this," Dillon said in a recent interview. "Modern-day slavery and human trafficking is far too easy to execute, and far too profitable."
After that 2003 band tour, the singer and songwriter became a man obsessed. He learned there are an estimated 27 million modern-day slaves around the world. He wondered how he could fight the trafficking and sexual exploitation of women and girls, bonded labor and indentured sweatshop servitude.
Dillon started offering up his band for benefit concerts. He produced a 2008 documentary, "Call+Response," which included songs and interviews with the likes of Julia Ormond, Ashley Judd, Cornel West and Madeleine Albright.
His first website, www.chainstorereaction.com , which helps consumers send e-letters to companies, was cited by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and used in the research for the California law signed by former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger in 2010.
While some states already prohibit forced labor and criminalize trafficking, the California Transparency in Supply Chains Act is the first to tackle the global supply chain.
The law affects an estimated 3,200 companies with a presence in California, including Walmart and Macy's. It requires retailers and manufacturers with gross annual receipts of more than $100 million to disclose what they've done to eliminate slavery in the global supply chain of their goods.
Slavery can mean a sweatshop in India or a cotton field in Burkina Faso, where indentured slaves or child laborers dyed or picked the cotton for those cheap-but-chic garments that found their way under Christmas trees.
The legislation introduced by Senate President Pro Tem Darrell Steinberg requires companies to audit and certify that their suppliers are complying with international labor standards, as well as provide training to supply-chain managers.
The California Chamber of Commerce and California Retailers Association were among those who argued the requirements would carry huge costs and that private businesses were being enlisted as de facto law enforcement agencies.
Supporters note the law simply requires companies to disclose their efforts — even if they've made none — to eradicate slavery and human trafficking from their supply chains. While there are no monetary penalties, the state tax board will provide the attorney general a list of those businesses that have not complied and the AG's office will determine what legal action to take.
Monica Richman, a New York partner with the law firm SNR Denton who represents large retailers and fashion brands, said some clients are concerned the law is too broad and the details too murky. But most companies want to do the right thing, she said, and view the law as a tool to benefit business and burnish their brands.
"There are so many really impressive companies in the fashion industry," Richman said. "And they don't want to be known for offering a $500 pocketbook made by a 9-year-old child."
Many big companies, such as GAP, Nike and Ford Motor Co, already adopted clean-labor policies after ugly reports about bonded, child or forced labor in their own supply chains.
Dillon insists Slavery Footprint is not about shaming businesses. It's about educating consumers and allowing them to determine where they will shop — then getting them to tell that story via social media.
"We let everyone know that we're not handing out torches and pitchforks," he said. "But we are developing very sharp carrots in the marketplace."
Slavery Footprint asks visitors to take an online survey about consumer products, clothing and food to determine how many slaves might have worked along the supply chain for those goods.
The online site uses data from several independent sources in compiling an individual consumer's footprint score, including reports from the U.S. Department of State, U.S. Department of Labor and international organizations. Its calculation is based in part on an analysis of hundreds of consumer products and the "likely number of forced laborers that have been involved in creating the product at some stage in the process of production," according to the website.
When women are asked about cosmetics, for example, a box notes: "Every day tens of thousands of American women buy makeup. Every day tens of thousands of Indian children mine mica, which is the little sparkles in the makeup."
The consumer can then share the total slave score on Twitter or Facebook, encourage others to take the survey and then get involved by sending ready-made electronic letters to retailers calling on them to be more diligent when sourcing supplies. A mobile app "Free World," allows you to find out more about your products at point of purchase.
"It allows you to mobilize your value set in a way that uses your free time to be able to free people," Dillon said. "We think the only brand that can really ever make sense is, 'Made in the Free World.'"
The State Department provided the Slavery Footprint grant so Dillon could try to replicate the highly successful "carbon footprint" campaign by environmentalists.
"He's on the cutting edge," said State Department Ambassador-at-Large Luis CdeBaca, who heads up the Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons and believes social media are key to fighting slavery.
CdeBaca recalls the case of an 8-year-old girl whose Egyptian parents sold her into slavery to a Cairo couple, who then smuggled her into Irvine, Calif. She was forced to work for years as a domestic, living in squalor and not allowed to go to school.
She was eventually rescued and in December, at 22, became a naturalized citizen who hopes to become federal agent.
"You see something like that and you realize that every one of those 27 million is an individual," CdeBaca said. "And we can save them. We can walk with them on their path to freedom, because these are all people who, if you just give them a chance, can do amazing things."
___
On the Internet:
Slavery Footprint: www.slaveryfootprint.org
State Department Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons: http://www.state.gov/g/tip
___
December 30, 2011 03:21 PM EST



Enhanced by Zemanta

Friday, December 10, 2010

Youth Radio Investigates: Trafficked Teen Girls Describe Life In 'The Game' : NPR

A girl in a police car
Enlarge Brett Myers /Youth Radio Oakland, Calif., in the San Francisco Bay Area, has been dubbed by the FBI as a "high-intensity child prostitution area." Oakland officials say that a third of teenage girls working in prostitution there were abducted and forced onto the streets, and 61 percent of teen prostitutes say they were raped as children.

December 6, 2010

Part 1 of 2

Youth Radio is an independent producer. For more than six months, the organization has been investigating child sex trafficking in Oakland, Calif. In this two-part report, it pieces together what life is like for girls who are forced into prostitution — and how law enforcement continues to criminalize girls the state legally defines as sexually exploited victims.

Last month, the FBI announced the results of Operation Cross Country V, a 40-city investigation that led to the rescue of 69 children who were being victimized through prostitution. More than 800 people, including 99 pimps, were arrested. 

According to the FBI, more than 100,000 children are sold for sex in the U.S. each year. In a two-part series, Youth Radio takes a look at the problem of child prostitution in the U.S. Today, two young women who recently escaped what's called "the game" share their stories.


"I'd wake up at 5; I'd be outside by 5:30," says Brittney, 19. "I would just wait and see what happened, whether it'd be in the streets or whether I'd be on the Internet. And then I won't be able to come back inside until like 2 o'clock in the morning, so I'd get only, like, three hours of rest."

Brittney, a former sex worker, agreed to share her story under the condition that her real name not be used. She's a native of Oakland, Calif., and only recently out of what's called "the game." Less than a year ago, Brittney was being forced to work as a prostitute on the Internet and on the streets of Oakland.

"I got kidnapped when I was 15," says Brittney. "I decided to cut school one day. I was in Oakland, on Havenscourt and Foothill, and all I heard was, 'Man, go get that girl!' And one of them came out and dragged me by my hair, and he pulled me into the car."

Brittney was the victim of a so-called guerrilla pimp — a person, usually a man, who uses force and fear to traffic women, many of whom are underage. Oakland police estimate that a third of teenage girls working in prostitution were abducted and forced onto the streets the way Brittney was.

She says that after she was kidnapped, at least six men gang-raped her. She was then driven to Sacramento, where her 32-year-old pimp put her out on the street as a prostitute. He took her phone, told her not to talk to anyone but "johns," and had his sister watch her so she wouldn't run. She was shuttled back and forth to work Oakland's red-light district.

A 'Romeo Pimp'
Darlene, whose name has been changed as well, came into "the game" a different way.
She entered her teens around the same time her native Oakland, as part of the San Francisco Bay Area, was named by the FBI as one of the 13 national hot spots for child prostitution.

Classmates talked about their boyfriends who had lots of money, and — like most kids in the Bay Area — she listened to music by Oakland rappers, whose lyrics about pimping glamorized "the game."

"A lot of it is glorified," says Darlene. "Oh, you're from Oakland. Everybody has dreads; everybody goes dumb; we pop pills, smoke a lot of weed; parties, sideshows and hos."

If you're not part of the scene, it's hard to believe that prostitution has become normal for so many in Oakland and other cities. But many see it as an alternative to desperate home lives, friends getting shot, no food on the table and absent parents. And pimps take advantage of that.

Darlene became a prostitute at the hands of what Oakland police call a "Romeo pimp." Now 18, she moved in with her boyfriend when she was 14, after she was kicked out of the house.

"On my 15th birthday, he was like, 'Well, you know, since you'll be staying with me, we need more food. We need to find a way to get some money'," says Darlene. "He's the one that, like, introduced me to prostitution, and I didn't see anything wrong with it."

Darlene says she later found out her then-18-year-old boyfriend had pimped other girls before. When he became her pimp, Darlene says, he told her what to do to make money. " 'This is how you look at the guys; this is what you tell them; these are what cars to stay away from; this is how much you charge.' "

On 'The Track'
International Boulevard, one of Oakland's busiest streets, is what pimps call "The Track." In a 50-block span on one recent day, there were some 20 girls. Some of them were posted on street corners; others were hanging by bus stops, or just walking the same blocks over and over.

The guys who work at one of the many taco trucks on International Boulevard say that every day, pimps use their parking lot to drop off girls and hang out. They say it's common to see pimps beating girls.
While most Oakland residents drive by and don't think twice about what's going on here, the people in this neighborhood do.

"They're always there," says Frank Pardo, whose mother owns Yoyi's Bridal shop. "You always see them, and some of them are quite beautiful, looking like straight models."

Just down the street, a teenage girl in a short red dress is crying on a bench. She has blood coming from her mouth. A business owner who runs a clothing store says he saw the whole thing: The man who punched the girl appeared to be her pimp, and stole her purse.

The witness would not identify himself by name, for fear of retribution from sex traffickers. That's the same reason he gave for not calling the police.

Brittney and Darlene each survived the many months they spent turning tricks on International Boulevard and meeting johns through the Internet. Brittney says her pimp got her hooked on drugs to keep her working around the clock and eating only one meal a day, usually a burger from McDonald's.

"It's not the best deal to have sex with 15 different guys in one day and only get a cheeseburger at the end of it," says Alameda County Assistant District Attorney Sharmin Bock. Bock compares the girls' situation to being brainwashed by a cult.

"Remember Guyana and Jim Jones, where everybody's drinking that Kool-Aid drink? Well, that's exactly what these girls have had. Let's call it pimp juice. They've all had it, and they can't see past either their affection for their trafficker, or their fear of him," says Bock.

A History Of Violence
According to a recent survey of social service providers in Oakland and the rest of the county, 61 percent of the teen prostitutes they see say they were raped as children.

That's what happened to Brittney. She says she was raped by her stepfather and years later by her trafficker. Brittney tries to understand how she kept going back to her pimp.

"I knew what he was capable of," she says. "He'd beat me and he'd rape me, he'd beat me and he'd rape me, and I just kept going back until I ended up being pregnant by him. And he beat me so bad that I ended up having a miscarriage."

"I got shot at quite a few times," says Darlene, who had been arrested for prostitution and robbery in the year after she ran away from her father's house. She wanted to go home.

"I used to fantasize about boys that are gangstas. 'Oh, they get hecka money and they're just gangsta and cute, and it's cool,' " says Darlene. "That's OK when you're in high school. After that, what are you gonna do with your life? You're gonna be in jail or you're gonna be dead, and I don't want part of either one of those."

A New Life
After her last arrest, Darlene joined a program that transitions girls off the streets. Brittney got out, too, shortly after she had the miscarriage.

"Six days later — it was a Sunday — and he put me on East 14th. I told him that I didn't want to be out on Sundays because I had a bad feeling about Sundays. And I saw my aunt. And my aunt ended up snatching me up and putting me in the car. And then she took me to my mom's house," says Brittney.

"Two days later, police came knocking on my door, saying I had a warrant."
That warrant put Brittney back in jail for prostitution and, like Darlene, she enrolled in a community program.
It's been less than a year since Brittney and Darlene turned their lives around. Now they are both working with community organizations to help other girls escape sex trafficking. Darlene and Brittney consider themselves survivors, navigating a new life.

"I got back in school and I graduated high school with, like, 20 extra credits," says Darlene, who has two jobs and is planning to attend college. "When I was 15, I didn't see myself alive at the age of 18. And now I am 18, and I can look back and say, 'You know, I've been through all that, and I've come out of it.' It feels wonderful."

Read More From Youth Radio


Child Prostitution In The U.S., By The Numbers

100,000-300,000: The number of children sold for sex in the U.S. each year

12-14: The average age at which girls first become victims of prostitution

11-13: The average age at which boys and transgendered youth enter into prostitution

55 percent: The proportion of girls living on the streets in the U.S. engaged in formal prostitution

30 percent: The proportion of youth living in shelters who are sexually exploited

75 percent: The proportion of girls engaged in prostitution who are working for a pimp

One-fifth: The fraction of exploited children who are trafficked nationally

$150,000-$200,000: The amount a pimp can make each year, per child

76 percent: The proportion of transactions for sex with underage girls conducted via the Internet

Sources: Justice Department, National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, Demi & Ashton Foundation

National Hot Spots

In 2003, the FBI's Crimes Against Children Unit identified these 13 U.S. cities as having a high incidence rate of child prostitution.
  1. Los Angeles
  2. Minneapolis
  3. Dallas
  4. Detroit
  5. Tampa, Fla.
  6. Chicago
  7. San Francisco
  8. San Diego
  9. Miami
  10. New York City
  11. Washington, D.C.
  12. Las Vegas
  13. St. Louis
Source: FBI

Part 2 of 2


In Part 2 of this report, Youth Radio explores what local police and the FBI are doing to combat sex trafficking. Read it here.

Source: NPR 


Youth Radio Investigates: Trafficked Teen Girls Describe Life In 'The Game' : NPR
Enhanced by Zemanta

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Oakland’s Sexually Trafficked Youth: Arrest or Treat These Victims? (Series Part 6) | Oakland Local

Published on Friday, May 07, 2010
Last updated on 07:05AM, Wednesday, May 12, 2010

"The Corridor" by 1Flatworld, via Flickr: http://bit.ly/aIbrKj (CC license

By Sarah Terry-Cobo

This is Part 6 of an eight-part, four-day Oakland Local investigative series on youth sex trafficking.

The Oakland Police Department believes it must arrest girls involved in prostitution to get them off the streets for their own safety. Without a safe residential treatment facility, officers say, juvenile hall presents a better alternative than leaving them on the streets.

"We used to just warn them and let them stay out on the streets," said Vice Unit Investigator Jim Saleda during one of the department's operations. "I learned my lesson when I found the body of one of the girls a week later, mutilated in Mosswood Park."

Some fierce advocates in the Bay Area are working to change laws that punish young victims, in addition to providing services to exploited young women...

PREVIOUSLY in this series | NEXT in this series
Complete series index | Take action!

But police say, unfortunately, conducting vice sweeps is an important way to gather information about johns and traffickers who perpetrate sexual exploitation -- the people they hope to put behind bars.

Consequently, young girls continue to be processed by the criminal justice system. This means they get handcuffed by police, taken to a staging area for paperwork, and later are transported in a police van to jail or juvenile hall.

Victims often don't think they're exploited

According to Alameda County Deputy District Attorney Sharmin Eshraghi Bock and other experts, many sexually exploited girls are brainwashed, and few realize pimps are exploiting them. At the staging area in East Oakland during a police operation, officers loaded nearly a dozen women into the back of a large van with bars on the windows.

"They treatin' us like fuckin' animals!" screamed one woman. Even though the nonprofit group Bay Area Women Against Rape (BAWAR) is on scene to offer snacks, water and services to the women, it can be difficult to win their trust.

Officer Saleda said the women and girls police often pick up on these sweeps won't accept help from BAWAR the first several times. Some never accept help, he said.

The women who are arrested will be processed at police headquarters in downtown Oakland. If they have no warrants and are not on probation, they will return to the streets a few hours later, Saleda said.

During questioning, police officers remind detained minors that they are not criminals.

"You know you are a victim, right?" one undercover officer said to a young girl in an interview room. "This is not your fault," both interviewing officers told the girl, who sat wrapped in a blue blanket. Like so many other young women, she is sent to Alameda County's Juvenile Justice Center, high in the hills of San Leandro.

Processing sexually exploited youth through the criminal justice system does help police gather crucial information, but some community advocates criticize this method.

Jennifer Kim, a policy advocate with Books Not Bars (an Oakland-based nonprofit for families with children in youth jails) acknowledged that police want to help. However, she said, she is concerned by the system's response to the girls' situation.

"It's kind of a disconnect," she said, "with treating these young people as victims -- but yet in order to give them the support that they need, you have to criminalize them first."

Kim thinks that, if the juvenile justice system can't treat the root problems of youth sexual exploitation, then it only serves as punishment to the children.

From handcuffs to juvenile hall

Juvenile hall may not be pleasant, but it can provide the structure some sexually exploited youth desperately need but rarely receive. Clark L. Blackmore is a supervisor who has worked at the Alameda County Juvenile Justice Center for two decades. On a rainy day in early February, he provided a tour of the detention portion of the three-building complex.

His job involves monitoring youth on home supervision with GPS tracking devices. However, during the tour, Blackmore behaved more like a guidance counselor to the kids he encountered.

"Hey, good morning, how are you doing? How are your parents?" Blackmore asked a young man waiting in the medical clinic. One teenage girl asked him about seeing her infant. (To prevent the spread of H1N1 flu, no small children are allowed in the facility -- even when a young mother has not see her child in weeks or months.)

This detention facility, which opened two years ago, seemed much less sterile than one might imagine. Art by local artists lined the walls on every floor, and some rooms had carpeting. The open-air courtyard includes a basketball court, as well as a grill for occasional outdoor cooking.

All main doors in the detention facility are monitored by cameras. They only open after someone in the control room checks a camera for that door and grants access. As youths walk down the hall, they must clasp their hands behind their backs, like invisible handcuffs. Visitors must stand against the wall until they pass.

An average day at juvenile hall is structured. It includes a full day of school (8 a.m. to 2:40 p.m.), covering all the subjects you would find in public school. Some classes offer opportunities for music, art and recreation -- but these are often the first to be cut in a budget crisis.

"They have the capacity to learn."

"You have to make the classroom a place where they want to go," Blackmore said, as he gestured to a row of computers lining the back wall of a classroom filled with female students. Alameda County's Juvenile Justice Center offers computer classes, with access to the Internet. "This shows they have the capacity to learn; it just depends on what you want to learn."

Some people do not think juvenile hall is an appropriate place for victims of sex trafficking. However, it does appear to be a healthier environment than overcrowded, underfunded public schools. All children in the Justice Center receive complete medical treatment, three meals a day and more modern classrooms with a smaller student-to-teacher ratio.

Blackmore smiled and mentioned how, every now and then, he "sees the kid side come out of them" -- especially on Saturdays when staff show cartoons in the morning.

"They're not bad kids," Blackmore said. But under the influence of peer pressure, "they just make bad decisions."

Compared to how they acted at the county's former detention facility, Blackmore said he has seen an improvement in the kids' behavior at the new facility. (The $176 million facility was completed in 2007, replacing a 299-bed juvenile hall that dated back to 1954.) However, it's not the specially designed building that helps kids understand they are in a safe place.

"If you don't have the right staff, then it'll be a wild house up there. They have to care about the kids," said Blackmore. Sometimes staff help parents learn about their kids -- but for kids who don't have parents to pick them up, or homes to return to, going to a group home might sometimes seem worse than staying in juvenile hall.

NEXT in this series: Part 7, Rescuing Trafficked Youth: Building a House for Kids With No Home...

COMPLETE SERIES INDEX: Youth Trafficking in Oakland

This story was produced under a fellowship sponsored by the
G.W. Williams Center for Independent Journalism, a project of Tides
Center.

We also would like to thank Robert Rosenthal and California Watch for their support -- as well as our reporters Barbara Grady and Sarah Terry-Cobo, and photographer Alison Yin -- for their amazing work.

Support more independent quality reporting like this! Please donate to Oakland Local on Spot.us. We are seeking additional support for continued coverage.

About Sarah Terry-Cobo
Sarah Terry-Cobo's picture
Sarah is a freelance reporter and a 2009 graduate of the University of California, Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism and Latin American Studies programs. She specializes in science and environmental policy issues, but also has a keen interest in immigration and Latin American affairs. Her work has previously appeared in The Oakland Tribune, Forbes.com and GreenBiz.com. She is currently reporting and blogging for Carbon Watch, a joint venture of the Center for Investigative Reporting and Frontline/World. She researched and wrote the stories in Oakland Local's youth trafficking series with the support of a fellowship from the G.W. Williams Center for Independent Journalism.


Oakland’s Sexually Trafficked Youth: Arrest or Treat These Victims? (Series Part 6) | Oakland Local

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]